I’m so unathletic, I once broke my leg walking up a flight of stairs. Didn’t fall — just walked.
I came to school the next day with a cast, trying to come up with some excuse, like –
Young Josh: “I was banging this chick…really hard.”
Friend: “You fall down a flight of stairs?”
Young Josh: “Nope. Just walked up.”
My parents signed me up for sports because they thought I was gay — and what better way to ensure that your child is straight than by enrolling him in man-on-man wrestling?
I used to pin myself before the matches even began. I’d just throw myself on the floor, like –
Josh: “I’ll be here eventually. Let’s just skip the embarrassing part.”
Then I failed at baseball, soccer, and YMCA basketball where I’d perform intentional pratfalls during the games. (I thought I was communicating, “I don’t want to be here. I’m an entertainer.” Apparently my mom got the message, “Your son may be mentally handicapped.”)
It didn’t help that I played on one of those underdog teams that finally got that one chance to win…and still blew it.
After every game, we had to line up to shake the other players’ hands. I hated that. The other players were all like –
Other team: “Good game…good game…good game.”
We were like –
Us: “Good game.” {quietly} “Go fuck yourself.” {to the next person} “Good game.” {quietly} “You condescending prick.”
Eventually, my parents gave up. My mom was like –
Mom: {to my father} “You know what? He’s probably not gay. This is embarrassing for both of us.”
My dad was still disappointed –
Dad: “You don’t want to go out there and have fun with kids your age?”
Josh: “No, thanks. I’d rather stay at home and perpetuate yet another negative Jewish stereotype.”
* * *
Then my mom put me in tap-dancing lessons. (I had to do something physical.)
I remember the moment she bought those tap shoes. It was a pivotal, out-of-body, experience. I remember staring at myself, like –
Out-of-body Josh: “You’re looking at tap shoes, buddy. It’s gonna be a loooong road.”
…and then I was cheap; so, I reasoned, “Well, these’ll also have to function as my black shoes.” Walking around in public like, Tck-a-tuk. Tck-a-tuk. Tck-a-tuk.
That was actually around the time I fell down the stairs. Everyone knew I fell because they heard, Tuh-tcka-tuh-tuh.
I hit the floor, like –
Josh: {in pain} “AGHH!!!” {then} “Jazz hands.”
* * *
In high school, my opinion on physical activity hadn’t really changed. I remember being in P.E., having finished a game of one-on-one with some athletic kid. He boasted –
Athletic kid: “Uhh!!! I beat yo’ ass, fool!”
I shrugged it off.
Josh: “Yeah, and your parents are alcoholics. Put in perspective, man.”
After that, I managed to get out of sports through notes my mom wrote. They’d say –
“Please excuse Josh from any physical activity. He has a broken spirit.
Also, he’s a giant pussy.”
When that didn’t work, I realized the P.E. teachers were all perverts who let the girls get away with anything; so, I befriended the chicks — and instead of playing soccer, we would all go sit in the corner and talk about boys.
They’d ask –
Girls: “Don’t you worry the boys think you’re gay?”
I replied –
Josh: “Of course not. I just don’t want them to see me play sports and call me a ‘fag.’”


